Understanding Contrastive Learning through Variational Analysis and Neural Network Optimization Perspectives

The SimCLR method for contrastive learning of invariant visual representations has become extensively used in supervised, semi-supervised, and unsupervised settings, due to its ability to uncover patterns and structures in image data that are not directly present in the pixel representations. However, the reason for this success is not well-explained, since it is not guaranteed by invariance alone. In this paper, we conduct a mathematical analysis of the SimCLR method with the goal of better understanding the geometric properties of the learned latent distribution. Our findings reveal two things: (1) the SimCLR loss alone is not sufficient to select a good minimizer -- there are minimizers that give trivial latent distributions, even when the original data is highly clustered -- and (2) in order to understand the success of contrastive learning methods like SimCLR, it is necessary to analyze the neural network training dynamics induced by minimizing a contrastive learning loss. Our preliminary analysis for a one-hidden layer neural network shows that clustering structure can present itself for a substantial period of time during training, even if it eventually converges to a trivial minimizer. To substantiate our theoretical insights, we present numerical results that confirm our theoretical predictions.