Neural Constraints on Cognitive Experience and Mental Health
Journal:
arXiv
Published Date:
Mar 18, 2025
Abstract
Understanding how neural dynamics shape cognitive experiences remains a
central challenge in neuroscience and psychiatry. Here, we present a novel
framework leveraging state-to-output controllability from dynamical systems
theory to model the interplay between cognitive perturbations, neural activity,
and subjective experience. We demonstrate that large-scale fMRI signals are
constrained to low-dimensional manifolds, where affective and cognitive states
are naturally organized. Furthermore, we provide a theoretically robust method
to estimate the controllability Gramian from steady-state neural responses,
offering a direct measure of the energy required to steer cognitive outcomes.
In five healthy participants viewing 2,185 emotionally evocative short videos,
our analyses reveal a strong alignment between neural activations and affective
ratings, with an average correlation of $r \approx 0.7$. In a clinical cohort
of 255 patients with major depressive disorder, biweekly Hamilton Rating Scale
trajectories over 11 weeks significantly mapped onto these manifolds,
explaining approximately 20% more variance than chance ($p < 10^{-10}$,
numerically better than chance in 93% reaching statistical significance in
one-third of subjects). Our work bridges dynamical systems theory and clinical
neuroscience, providing a principled approach to optimize mental health
treatments by targeting the most efficient neural pathways for cognitive
change.
